Partner Adrian Dalton discusses two important cases on vicarious liability
People sometimes wonder why is that when an employee of a business or other organisation does something wrong it is possible to bring a legal case not only against the individual but also the organisation concerned.
There are various reasons why it is possible to do this. One of the most important is a legal idea called “vicarious liability”.
Broadly – vicarious liability states that if somebody commits a criminal or negligent act in the course of her employment then her employer may be held responsible for that act even if it may seem “obvious” that the employer did not give permission for the act to take place.
There have been two really important cases about this idea recently both decided in the Supreme Court (which used to be called the House of Lords until a few years ago).
- Cox v The Ministry of Justice
In this case the claimant Cox was in prison. Cox was working as a catering manager. He got injured because of the negligent act of a fellow prisoner who was also doing paid kitchen work at the prison.The first judge considering the matter found that the Ministry of Justice was liable for the negligent act of the other prisoner. So did the Court of Appeal. The Ministry of Justice appealed against the decision and so it went to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court said – in outline – that the Ministry of Justice could not avoid liability by arguing that the prisoner who committed the negligent act was not really an employee.
The decision in this case is likely to offend some people in the way prisoners asserting their rights often seems to do for some reason (not a point of view shared by the writer of this blog who genuinely fails to follow why it is that some commentators appear to think that prisoners ought not to have any rights at all).
But if you step back from it and give it a moment’s thought you can see that it makes sense. For instance – there have been thousands of cases brought against the Roman Catholic Church on the basis of vicarious liability in various countries around the world.
If the Church had been able successfully to argue in those cases that it was not liable because priests sexually molesting children were obviously not working in their capacity as priests- and of course they weren’t – and/or that the church was not responsible for them doing that then many many people would have gone without justice and uncompensated.
Looked at like that you can see that the doctrine of vicarious liability does need to be widely drawn in order to ensure access to justice.
- Mohamud v William Morrison Supermarkets
In this case a customer went to a petrol station kiosk and approached a member of staff there called K with an enquiry. (The supermarket owned and operated the kiosk). K swore at the customer – Mohamud – and then followed him outside and assaulted him.
Mohamud sued the supermarket on the basis of vicarious liability and the first judge who considered the case said the supermarket was not liable because there was not a sufficiently close connection between the assault and what K was employed to do (this is another way of stating the obvious fact that William Morrison does not employ people to assault members of the public). The Court of Appeal upheld that judgement so the matter went to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court said that what K did was inexcusable when he swore at Mohamud but it was within the field of activities assigned to him – that is: answering questions customers ask you. And then what happened after – the assault – was an unbroken sequence of events. In following Mohamud outside to assault him and order him to get off the premises K was purporting to act in the furtherance of the business of his employer. It had nothing to do with the merits of the case that it looked as though K was motivated in acting as he did by personal racism.
Again – one can see that if Mohamud had not had the right to sue Morrisons he would have been denied access to justice (since it is unlikely that K would have had enough money to compensate him). That same point would be likely to apply again in the case of abusive priests (since one cannot insure oneself personally against the possible financial consequences of acting in this way and very few priests are likely to be financially well off so as to be able to pay). Or to others who abuse positions of trust to prey upon children and other vulnerable people.
Blog by Adrian Dalton, Partner and Head of the Personal Injury department