Home › Open Letter to MPs

News

Open Letter to MPs

We recently sent an open letter to MPs regarding the wide ranging and we think very alarming changes proposed by the government as to how criminal legal aid will work in the future. Criminal legal aid is currently used to assist with the costs of legal representation of suspects in criminal investigations and defendants in criminal proceedings. Applications for criminal legal aid are already subject to both a means and merits test. The letter expresses our huge concerns regarding the new system as explained further in many blog posts including a recent one from Jeff Dean.

If you have your own concerns about the proposed changes you can do one thing easily which is to sign this e petition

Our open letter to MPs

Re : ‘Transforming Legal Aid’ Ministry of Justice Consultation Paper CP14/2013

We write regarding the above consultation and as one of the larger suppliers of legal aid criminal defence work within the area with offices in Sunderland, Newcastle and Gateshead. We employ around 100 people. We frequently represent some of the most vulnerable members of our local society.

You may be aware of the Consultation Paper and you may have already read some of the concerns being expressed in the local and national press. Commentators and those involved in the criminal justice system are opposed to these proposals.

Since formation we have covered criminal defence work along with a wide range of other areas of law. We have always maintained the provision of a quality service notwithstanding many difficult times in legal aid. We believe that it has been the quality of work that has allowed us to grow and develop into the successful practice that we are today. It is our view that the proposals are poorly thought through and have the potential to decimate the criminal justice system in a way that is completely irreversible.

We would welcome the opportunity to meet with you as a matter of urgency to discuss our concerns about the current proposals. We highlight below our main concerns.

  • Client Choice/Two tier system – No person whose case is funded under legal aid will be able to choose their own representation/solicitor; those who can afford to pay will be able to do so.
  • Access to justice – providers will be required to cover huge geographic areas further restricting people’s access to advice.
  • Reduction in Quality – There are clear incentives within the proposals for matters to be expedited at the expense of proper consideration – at least at the first instance. This will lead to distrust between solicitor and client and inevitably a reduction in the quality of service provided and an increased number of appeals and potential miscarriages of justice (with associated cost to the public purse). The Consultation Paper itself acknowledges that there will be a reduction in quality as the current system encourages competition through quality of work at a level that is according to the Government “above acceptable”.
  • The model – Contracts will be granted to providers on a price competitive tendering basis – the lowest bids will be successful. The arrangements proposed and the rates of pay mean that it will simply not be financially viable for most existing firms to bid.
  • The market – The proposals envisage a false market. Providers will be guaranteed a certain percentage of the work available in an area. This will be calculated purely on how many providers exist in that area (which in turn will be specified by the MoJ). Providers will have no ability to influence rates of pay; they will not be able to increase their volume of work; the quality of service provided will have no bearing on the amount of work allocated.
  • Reduction of providers – The numbers of firms providing this service will hugely reduce – the stated aim is from approximately 1600 to 400 nationally, and from approximately 50 to 10 in Northumbria. This has clear implications for the numbers of people who will lose their employment.
  • Timescales – This consultation has been brought forward at short notice. The timescales proposed demonstrate a complete lack of understanding on the part of the MoJ as to the level of restructuring envisaged.
  • We believe the concerns raised by the consultation paper and highlighted in this letter are far wider than our firms’ or our colleagues’ individual interests and strike at the very heart of the present criminal justice system. The impact on many of your constituents – practitioners, employees and those requiring advice and representation alike – cannot be understated. Many firms will simply cease to operate with the knock on effect on local businesses. No client being represented under public funding will have any choice over who represents them. The legal profession will stagnate. The effect on quality will be catastrophic and public confidence in the criminal justice system will be adversely effected.

Related Staff

Request a Callback